Artificial intelligence is a present reality shaping how our people pray, study Scripture, and seek spiritual guidance. It is changing how we work, communicate, create, learn, and make decisions. At Preston Trail, we want to use it wisely because it can help us steward our time, gifts, and resources more effectively as we help people find and follow Jesus Christ.
No policy can anticipate every AI tool or situation. These principles give us a shared foundation for wise discernment as we approach our work.
- AUTHORITY: AI cannot speak for God. 2 Timothy 3:16-17
- Scripture is our guiding authority, providing the final standard for theology, faith, and practice. AI cannot replace prayer, personal study, biblical community, spiritual formation, or dependence on the Holy Spirit.
- RESPONSIBILITY: AI assists. Humans discern and own the outcome. 1 Thessalonians 5:21
- Technology is not morally neutral in its effects. AI can help us process, research, organize, create, and be more effective. AI can also be confidently wrong, incomplete, biased, or simply not very good. It cannot replace human judgment, relationships, or spiritual discernment.
- When you use AI, you remain responsible for the outcome. Check the facts. Apply your expertise. Make sure the final work is something you can confidently stand behind.
- RESTRAINT: Some things shouldn’t be outsourced. Colossians 3:23
- AI is useful when it can reduce routine work and create capacity for the main thing. But the goal isn’t always to do more, faster. It’s to better steward what we’ve been given as we move the mission forward.
- Relationships, pastoral care, spiritual discernment, meaningful judgment, and other responsibilities that depend on human presence or expertise shouldn’t be handed over to AI.
- INTEGRITY: Protect the trust we’ve earned. 1 Peter 5:2-4
- People trust us with their information, stories, and experiences. They also trust us to represent ourselves honestly. We steward that trust by maintaining integrity in our use of AI.
- Be thoughtful about what is shared with AI tools. Use church information only in approved systems and never use AI to fabricate or misrepresent a person, story, ministry moment, or experience.
- ROLES: AI doesn’t expand your lane. Romans 12:4-8
- AI can help you do the work entrusted to you. It doesn’t give new authority, expertise, or permission to bypass people and processes that would otherwise be part of the work.
- A new tool doesn’t automatically change who owns the work.
Section 1: Tools, Technology, and Approval
This policy governs how Preston Trail staff, elders, serve team members, and contractors use AI for church-related work. It applies to generative AI; image, video, and voice tools; transcription and analysis tools; AI features built into other software; and emerging AI technologies.
Approved platforms, accounts, and integrations are managed by the Tech team in partnership with the Ministry Operations Director, as directed by the Executive Pastor. Claude Enterprise is our primary approved platform. Appendix A outlines platforms and their approved uses. If it is not listed or is listed as an unapproved platform, do not use it.
Prior to purchasing, subscribing to, or starting to use a new platform not covered in this policy, submit a Platform Support ticket and receive explicit approval. This includes paid and free options, trials, and personal subscriptions.
The same requirement applies before:
- Turning on AI features in software we already use
- Connecting AI to a Preston Trail system or data
- Using AI to communicate automatically on behalf of the church
- Launching or sharing an AI-powered app, site, chatbot, or automation
- Piloting an AI use not covered by this policy
When in doubt, ask before you purchase, connect, automate, launch, or pilot.
Section 2: Using AI in Your Work
“When the work is spiritual, you create, then consult AI. Your sermon, your counsel, your prayers: those start with you wrestling, not with a prompt. AI can sharpen your thinking, but must not replace it.
When the work is operational, flip it. Let AI create and you revise. Schedules, summaries, first drafts of announcements: let the machine do the machine work so you can do the human work.”
— Carey Nieuwhof, Your Sermon Isn't Your Competitive Advantage Anymore
2.1 Personal and Church Data
Church data belongs to Preston Trail and to the people who entrusted it to us. It must be handled with the same care as a confidential pastoral conversation. AI trains itself and other models on the data it collects, which could inadvertently inform or surface in another user’s session.
Personal or sensitive information and church data should only be shared with AI through approved, church-governed systems and integrations. Information about a specific person may be used only within Preston Trail’s governed environment.
Personal information includes:
- Name and contact information
- Prayer requests
- Giving records
- Counseling or pastoral notes
- Attendance and engagement data
- Staff or personnel information
- Other confidential or protected church data
Do not export, copy, or store personal data outside Preston Trail-governed systems. This includes spreadsheets, local files, personal drives, standalone apps, websites, or other systems that have not been approved.
Serve team members may only access personal or protected church information through systems and information they have been formally authorized to use.
2.2 Research, Learning, and Brainstorming
AI can help you get started, explore possibilities, process information, or consider different perspectives.
Appropriate uses include:
- Brainstorming ideas, outlines, or starting points
- Summarizing articles, books, documents, or other resources
- Exploring historical context, commentaries, cross-references, or theological perspectives
- Organizing your own thinking and comparing information
Treat AI-generated information as a starting point, not as fact. Verify quotes, statistics, Scripture references, and other information before relying on or sharing it.
2.3 Administrative and Operational Work
AI can help reduce routine administrative work and create space for the responsibilities that need more of your attention.
Appropriate uses include:
- Drafting emails, agendas, project plans, and other working documents
- Summarizing meeting notes and identifying action items
- Transcribing meetings, messages, or interviews with appropriate consent
- Organizing information and comparing reports
- Helping structure plans, processes, schedules, or workflows
2.4 Written Content, Image, Video Generation
AI can guide exploration of creative directions and handle routine production work, allowing the user to focus more on the ministry.
Appropriate uses include:
- Brainstorming concepts, headlines, and creative directions
- Drafting, editing, proofreading, shortening, and adapting copy
- Removing backgrounds or distracting objects from images
- Minor retouching, audio cleanup, and reframing
- Adapting approved content for a different format or channel
Synthetic likenesses, voice clones, or deepfakes should not be created. We do not materially misrepresent or replicate people or moments. Images of minors require additional care and may never be used to generate new likenesses. Existing photo permissions and privacy standards always apply.
The broader the audience, the more human authorship and creative judgment matter. AI drafts and production work are a starting point, not finished creative, and using them does not change existing roles, approvals, or Creative team involvement. Our Brand Guidelines govern how Preston Trail is represented, including AI-assisted work. A person must shape the message, apply the appropriate ministry context, and take responsibility for the final result.
2.5 Ministry and Pastoral Care
AI can help you research, prepare, process ideas, or think through a situation. It should not become a substitute for human relationships or spiritual discernment that ministry requires. Self-leadership includes processing with Scripture and prayer before engaging with AI.
Do not use AI to:
- Solely author pastoral counseling or shepherding responses
- Solely author personalized prayers for someone in your care
- Solely author devotional content or ministry curriculum without appropriate human, theological, and ministry ownership
- Generate prophetic words, claims of divine revelation, or other content presented as coming from God
- Make final decisions about spiritual guidance and other matters requiring collaborative discernment and human judgment
- Replace pastoral interaction with an AI chatbot or automated experience
2.6 Sermons and Teaching
AI can support sermon and teaching preparation, but it should not replace personal study, theological conviction, or dependence on the Holy Spirit.
AI may assist with:
- Researching biblical languages, historical context, cross-references, or theological perspectives
- Brainstorming message structures, illustrations, objections, or application ideas
- Editing or proofreading something you have written
- Transcribing a spoken draft into written form
The Integrity Test
Before teaching something AI helped you prepare, you should be able to say:
- I studied it. I personally studied the biblical text and can explain and defend my interpretation.
- I believe it. The theological convictions and application are mine, not simply what AI generated.
- I checked it. I verified quotes, citations, statistics, Scripture references, and other factual claims.
- It's true. Stories presented as personal experiences happened to me, and other stories are accurately represented or attributed.
- AI assisted me. It helped my process; it did not replace my preparation or spiritual discernment.
2.7 Building and Sharing AI-Powered Tools
AI has made it possible for almost anyone to build user experiences that work, and we want to support that innovation and creativity. With great power comes great responsibility. We must be mindful about where tools are deployed, because a tool that leaves our systems takes private church information with it.
If you build a website, app, chatbot, or other tool for your work at Preston Trail, submit a Platform Support ticket before it goes anywhere outside the approved platform where it was built. This applies whether you used AI to build it or not, and whether you are sharing it with the public or just a few people. A church tool should not live on a public website, a personal account, or be downloaded and run on a personal phone or computer.
Sharing your tool with staff inside an approved platform is fine and does not need a ticket. Those platforms keep it limited to staff and off the public internet.
Have an idea? Experiment freely within our approved tools, then submit a Platform Support ticket so we can work on it together.
Section 3: Decision-Making, Authenticity, and Accountability
How we use AI should reinforce the trust people place in Preston Trail. People should be able to trust that what we communicate is true and authentically represents the story God is writing here.
3.1 Decisions That Require Human Ownership
AI can help you process information, explore options, prepare for conversations, or think through a decision.
AI should not make final decisions about:
- Hiring, performance, or discipline
- Spiritual guidance
- Financial approvals or expenditures
- Legal matters
- Other decisions requiring pastoral discernment or established approval processes
AI may help you think through these situations, but it does not replace prayer, human judgment, qualified expertise, or group discernment.
3.2 Represent Reality Honestly
AI should not be used to fabricate or misrepresent:
- A fictional ministry moment, event, testimony, or experience in a way that could reasonably be understood as real
- A real person’s identity, likeness, words, actions, or personal experience
- A story or illustration as something that happened when it did not
3.3 Be Transparent About AI’s Role
Routine AI assistance when used as described above does not need to be disclosed.
But when AI plays a significant role in published content, consider whether people could reasonably misunderstand how the content was created or who authored it. When disclosure is appropriate, be clear about AI’s role. If you're unsure whether you need to disclose your use of AI, reach out to the Communications team.
For sermons and teaching, significant AI involvement beyond routine research, editing, or transcription should be disclosed to the appropriate ministry or teaching team. Public disclosure is left to pastoral discretion.
3.4 Intellectual Property
AI doesn’t give us permission to copy someone else’s work. Don’t use AI to intentionally imitate or reproduce protected work in ways we wouldn’t otherwise permit.
3.5 You Own Your Work
Using AI does not reduce your personal or professional responsibility for the final work.
If inaccurate or misrepresented content reaches our people, such as a fabricated quote, a false statistic, an incorrect citation, or a misleading image, notify your SLT Lead and Communications team so that an appropriate correction can be issued.
3.6 When You’re Not Sure
AI will continue to change, and this policy cannot anticipate every situation. When a use isn’t clearly addressed, return to our guiding principles: AUTHORITY, RESPONSIBILITY, RESTRAINT, INTEGRITY, and ROLES.
If you're still unsure, submit a Platform Support ticket before moving forward.
3.7 Evolution and Training
The Ministry Operations Director is responsible for working with Tech to evaluate current and emerging tools (including those submitted by staff through the Platform Support ticketing system) and determining how they can best support our ministries. This policy will be reviewed and updated as technology, church systems, and our use of AI evolve.
Staff will receive practical training and resources on approved AI tools and responsible use, tailored to their roles.
Acknowledgment
By continuing in your role at Preston Trail Community Church, you agree to follow this policy. If you accidentally enter sensitive information into an unapproved AI tool, you will submit a Platform Support Ticket to determine next steps.
Contractors producing content or handling data on behalf of Preston Trail are subject to the applicable requirements of this policy and must disclose in writing when AI will meaningfully contribute to a deliverable.
Appendix A: AI Tool Reference
| Tool | Status | Approved Use | Restrictions |
| Claude Enterprise | Approved / Governed | Primary approved AI platform for staff work. See Section 2: Using AI in Your Work. | Enterprise privacy protections apply. Follow the data standards in Section 2.1: Personal and Church Data. |
| Teamflect | Approved / Governed | AI transcription of meeting recordings and generation of task and meeting related resources. | No sensitive data. Use limited to meeting content and the tasks that come out of it. |
| Planning Center | Approved/Governed | AI tools directly accessible from the Planning Center platform are approved for use with data accessible by Planning Center. | Enterprise privacy protections apply. Follow the data standards in Section 2.1: Personal and Church Data. |
| Online Giving | Approved/Governed | AI tools directly accessible from the Online Giving platform are approved for use with data accessible by Online Giving. | Enterprise privacy protections apply. Follow the data standards in Section 2.1: Personal and Church Data. |
| Microsoft Copilot | Approved / Governed (discouraged) | Permitted to access content within Preston Trail's Microsoft environment. | Should be avoided in favor of Claude due to capability limitations and data privacy concerns. Do not treat output as authoritative. |
| Google AI / Gemini | Unapproved / Personal | General information gathering through Google Search only. Google's AI responses are embedded in ordinary search results, so incidental exposure is unavoidable and acceptable. | No Preston Trail data of any kind. Not approved for official work product. Not reimbursable. |
| ChatGPT | Unapproved / Personal | Not approved for Preston Trail work. | No Preston Trail data, sensitive or otherwise. Not reimbursable. |
| Grok | Unapproved / Personal | Not approved for Preston Trail work. | No Preston Trail data, sensitive or otherwise. Not reimbursable. |
| All other AI tools | Unapproved / Personal | Not approved for Preston Trail work. Any tool not listed above is unapproved by default until reviewed by the Tech team. | No Preston Trail data, sensitive or otherwise. Not reimbursable. Submit a Platform Support ticket to request review of a new tool. |